A case for not testing…

Homeschoolers have their own opinions about whether or not their children will take standardized tests.  We haven’t had to come to a final conclusion on this issue yet because of the ages of our children and the laws here in Tennessee.

Today this conversation with my 8 year old, 2nd grade boy took place.

Foster: “Mommy, does D R then a dot stand for doctor?”

Me: “Yes. But it’s not a dot, it’s a period.”

Foster: “I like to call it a dot.”

Me: “But it’s called a period and a comma is not a curve.”

Foster: “It is a curve. You draw a curve. I like to call it a curve.”

Me: “Get back to work.”

We do 2 different types of grammar curriculum and write letters often.
As you can see, Foster would possibly get the identification of a period and comma wrong on one of those fill-in-the-bubble tests.

Unless it looked like this:  

Q: What do you call the punctuation mark used at the end of a statement?

            A) a question mark
            B) a period
            C) a comma
            D) whatever you want to call it

2 thoughts on “A case for not testing…

  1. Unknown's avatar
    Joan Concilio Otto April 12, 2012 at 3:22 am Reply

    I LOVE IT! That's my daughter's “problem,” too. She's got a very particular way of thinking. You'll see something like, “What's the author's purpose for writing this passage?” and Sarah's answer would be, “Whatever the author says.” In other words – she's not going to try to guess someone else's purpose! 🙂

    Love it. Except at test time.

    Like

  2. Unknown's avatar
    Becky April 14, 2012 at 1:22 pm Reply

    Love it…absolutely hilarious! I'm so glad you can find the humor in the every day. I struggle to do this at times.

    Like

Leave a reply to Joan Concilio Otto Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.